10 Best Pacifiers For Breastfed Babies In 2021

Although its use is a hotly debated topic, pacifiers are undoubtedly one of those baby essentials that  eventually becomes your BFF and sanity savior, especially when you have a fussy baby who is easily irritated. Myth or no myth, the importance of a pacifier cannot be over-emphasized. In fact, according to observational studies, the best pacifiers for breastfed babies help build a better breastfeeding bond between moms and babies.

Babies don’t just suckle for milk. They also do it for safety, comfort, and security. Having a pacifier only a reach away will make it possible for you to do some chores at home, go grocery shopping, have a peaceful Thanksgiving dinner, without your little one making a fuss. The pacifier is practically a soothing buddy that can easily comfort your baby when they are unsettled.

But how do you know the best baby pacifier suitable for your child? For all it is, y baby is the one that would be clutching onto the pacifier, so you may have to buy a few to find the perfect one they’re comfortable with. Remember the happier mood for the baby together with a relaxed mom can help in better breastfeeding. Ideal for both bottle-fed and breastfed babies.

Are Pacifiers Good For Babies?

Pacifiers are a great tool that mimics a nipple and is different from a milk bottle as they are just for comfort. Pacifiers are made of plastic or rubber to calm a baby. You may want to buy it for your baby to satisfy their sucking impulses. If it’s not yet feeding time, using a pacifier helps to quiet & calm a baby.

Pacifiers are not bad for your baby. You just need to follow specific guidelines and recommendations. As with most well used baby products, you will need to replace  the pacifiers every once in a while.

Best Buy Pacifiers For Baby & Newborn

Pacifiers come in different sizes, shapes, types, and colors. They are also made in different ways and with various materials. Some have naturally shaped nipples, while some have orthodontic ones. Sometimes parents find it hard to make the right choice for baby.

Every baby is different and reacts differently to various pacifiers. We have listed the best pacifiers to help you make the right decision.

1. Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

best pacifier for breastfed babyHospitals across the US use the Philips Avent Soothie pacifier as it helps soothe and calm newborns. Being made of hospital-grade, durable silicone without any odor or taste. So, it is highly recommended for your baby as it lasts a long time.

It has smooth and firm nipple which doesn’t get discolored, sticky, or misshapen so quickly. It has been recommended by over 2000 hospitals nationwide. It has a one-piece, a safe design that adheres to the standards of the American Academy of Pediatrics for newborns.

This pacifier is also made of BPA free material. You may boil pacifier for five minutes or put it into Philips Avent steam sterilize. It also comes with snap-on dishwasher safe, hygienic caps.

A single piece is the best feature of this pacifier. It means the whole pacifier is made of solid medical grade silicone material. It avoids collecting bacteria, and it is straightforward to wash.

Since 1984, Philips Avent has been manufacturing and designing products inspired by nature and has been developed through clinical trials and years of research. Their product range includes bottle feeding, breastfeeding, newborn, and toddler feeding products and baby monitors.

Buy This From Amazon

2. Ryan & Rose All-in-One Pacifier and Teether

best pacifiers for breastfed babiesRyan & Rose All-in-One Pacifier is made of 100% medical-grade, PVC, BPA, phthalate, and latex-free silicone. US CPSIA and FDA have approved it. This pacifier is recommended for babies without teeth.

Both the teething toys and pacifiers are recommended for growing babies. This combo attaches well to a paci-clip when needed. The nipple can quickly be ticked off when it is being used as a teether.

The baby pacifier has a soft nipple, which mimics natural breastfeeding and palette development, and soother feels nice on the gums. It is also top-rack dishwasher safe to save time sterilizing it. It has got hygienic, one-piece design to avoid bacteria and dirt from building up.

To avoid the risk of choking, you need to inspect the pacifier before use, especially when the baby gains teeth. If you see any sign of damage, discard it quickly. Be sure your baby is sucking nipple to relax, not to chew it. Pop it in before each use when using it as a teether.

Be sure to replace it after four weeks for hygiene and safety. Don’t use it without proper supervision. Also, don’t tie it around your baby’s neck. Use it only with CPSIA compliant pacifier clips.

Buy This From Amazon

3. WubbaNub Infant Pacifier – Giraffe

bibs pacifierWubbaNub Infant pacifier is an award-winning product that is a combination of plush animal and original pacifier. Its unique giraffe design will become the best friend for your baby. It has got a unique style to remain around a baby’s mouth.

It is almost impossible to lose and easy to grasp. It will help your baby to soothe on her own. It is distributed in NICU, hospitals, and nursing units across the country and is made with hospital grade silicone pacifiers.

Its material is BPA, Phthalate, and PVC free and non-latex. Its one-piece durable design avoids germ buildup around the cracks. Wubbanub is a leading brand that performs safety testing on all its baby/infant care products before offering in the market.

Wubbanub Pacifier is highly suggested for newborn babies as it is packed in a clear polybag. If you have a limited budget, it is a bit on the expensive side. But your child might love giraffe if he or she loves soft toys. It scores high in design. However, it is less functional as compared to others, and it is ranked high for a breastfed baby.

This pacifier has an Amazon rating of 4+, and its colorful giraffe design is something your baby will fall in love with. It is made of non-latex medical-grade Soothie silicone, so there will be no grime or dirt buildup on cracks or any sticky residue which may cause discomfort.

Buy This From Amazon

4. Nookums Paci-Plushies Elephant Buddies – Pacifier Holder

best pacifiers for breastfed babies 2020Nookums Paci-Plushies elephant buddies pacifier can save you from the problem of looking for lost pacifiers all the time. You can easily find it on a snap.

Each Paci-Plushie pacifier can easily detach from the animal when it comes to sanitize and replace it. It has a massive ring that is flexible enough to attach to several pacifiers. It works well with pacifiers with a button shield.

Paci-Plushies plush toys make it easier to maneuver the pacifier for babies to improve their motor skills. It comes with huggable designs sized for small hands and textured for them to explore and touch. You can turn it into teether with Chillies Teether.

It contains purified water to store in the fridge. It helps soothe gums for children of all age groups. You can attach your favorite toy and let your baby enjoy the soothing power of the teether when keeping their fingers engaged with plush. If your baby grows up, you can make its soft animal his toy to ease the transition. Plush is also machine washable.

Buy This From Amazon

5. Brown’s HappyPaci 100% Silicone Pacifier

best pacifier for breastfed babiesDr. Brown’s HappyPaci 100% silicone pacifier makes it easier to soothe your baby. It is a soft silicone pacifier that is simply designed like a bottle nipple. It has been made easy to offer your baby a pacifier as Dr. Brown’s pacifier is shaped like a nipple. It is also the first choice for moms as it comes with HappyPaci’s one-piece material.

This silicone pacifier has a butterfly-shaped contoured shield that curves as per the baby’s face for utmost comfort, and it adds a lot of room for little cheeks and noses. It is sterilizer safe, easy to clean, and dishwasher (top rack) safe. You can also choose from different color choices.

The best part of this pacifier is that it is made of hospital-grade silicone. It is an excellent product as it gives the utmost peace of mind as the material is completely safe. It is the best BPA-free pacifier made of one-piece, solid silicone. It is also straightforward to wash and dishwasher safe.

It has a fantastic butterfly shape on this one-piece shield. All mothers love this pacifier for different reasons. It looks adorable, and the little butterfly shape is unique and delightful. Well, it has more benefits. Its shape curves away from her face. It provides ample comfort to the baby.

Buy This From Amazon

6. MAM Glow In the Dark Pacifiers

pacifiers for breastfed babiesMAM understands parenting is not an easy feat. This is why they make smart and user-friendly products. They have been engaged in rendering innovative baby care products for over 40 years, including pacifiers, cups, bottles, toothbrushes, and teethers. They all provide optimal care to babies and solutions to parents at all stages.

MAM Glow in the Dark Pacifier is designed to soothe your baby and care for oral development. Its SkinSoft nipple is readily accepted by infants, and it has a shield for the utmost breathability for the sensitive skin of your baby. The best part of this pacifier is that it glows in the dark. So, you can easily spot it at night. 

This nipple is made of clear, odorless, tasteless, and durable SkinSoft silicone. It has an anti-slip and unique surface to stay in the baby’s mouth. It has a large orthodontic symmetrical nipple for babies from 0 to 6 months old for proper development of their teeth, palate, and gums.

It has a larger shield to grow as your baby grows. Baby’s skin can breathe easily with its air holes and an inner surface. The pacifier can stay in the baby’s mouth upside down or right side up. You don’t have to worry about incoming palate or front teeth.

Buy This From Amazon

7. BIBS BPA-Free Natural Rubber Baby Pacifier

bibs pacifier reviewBased in Denmark, BIBS is a family-owned company which is aimed to create pacifiers with the best quality materials. BIBS has developed one of the most popular pacifiers in the world over the past 40 years, which is made of 100% natural rubber.

It has been known for making products that always deliver style, function, and premium quality. It has been a household name for decades, and BIBS BPA free Natural Rubber Baby pacifier is the best choice for moms and babies. It helps your baby to self soothe by exercising her sucking instinct in a very natural way.

It mimics both the softness and shape of a mother’s breast. Its classic look captures the look, which is both elegant and timeless. It comes in stunning vintage colors, which add a nostalgic feel. They have muted and matte colors that blend well with wholesome linen and cotton fabrics and carved toys.

They have classic appeal with an elegant look. Its nipple is made of 100% pure rubber, and its soft material allows your baby to soothe well.

Buy This From Amazon

8. Chicco NaturalFit Pacifier Clear Soft Silicone

pacifier for breastfed babyThe soft silicone of the Chicco Natural Fit Pacifier gives the natural and soft feel for babies from 0 to 12 months. With its ergonomic shield and one-piece construction, both moms and babies will like it.

Several top European orthodontists developed its grooves, tiny ridges, and angled shape on the nipple for natural movement and positioning of the tongue.

Its nipple shape has been designed to distribute the pressure of tongue over the palate. Its narrow base makes it very flexible with proper mouth closure. Natural Fit comes in different colors.

It has angled shaped, grooves, and tiny ridges to enable natural movement and positioning of the tongue and proper distribution of tongue’s pressure over the palate. Every pair of this pacifier comes in a sterilized case.

It adds more flexibility with a narrow base to the mouth. It has got an ergonomic shield that is curved and soft with ventilation holes for proper circulation to avoid skin irritation because of saliva.

Buy This From Amazon

9. Nanobébé Flexy Baby Pacifier for Breastfeeding Newborn

pacifier for newborn breastfed babyWe have a Pacifier from Nanobébé on our list, and this one is also available in 2 different sizes. The small size can be used for the babies who are between 0 months to 3 months, and the bigger size can be used for the babies who are over three months old.

There are four colors available in these Pacifiers, and you can choose as per your favorite color. In terms of design, the pacifier has an ergonomic curve that resembles the face contour and the pacifier curves around the nose and chin.

There are ventilation holes as well, which makes it further easy to use the pacifier.

In terms of the material, these pacifiers are made of soft silicone, and each pack contains two pacifiers. We really appreciate the design of this pacifier as it never becomes a choking hazard for the baby. This also promotes the oral growth of the baby since it resembles the shape of the nipple. Overall, it is one of the best pacifiers available in the market, which is BPA and Phthalate free.

Buy This From Amazon

10. Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Soother Pacifier

best paci for breastfed babiesThese Pacifiers from Tommee Tippee are made of super-soft silicone, and they are available in 2 sizes. The first size is basically for the babies who are between the age of 0 months to 6 months, and the second size is for the babies who are between the age of 6 months and 18 months.

You can choose the size as per the age of your baby. The good part is that they are very trustworthy as their design is inspired by the natural shape of the nipple.

As mentioned earlier, they are made of silicone, and there is no BPA in these pacifiers, which makes them safe to use. A lot of times, a pacifier may block the airflow for the baby, but you do not have to worry about this problem as the design has integrated curves and holes in the pacifier, which ensures a constant airflow.

It is also straightforward to clean these pacifiers, and you can even boil them since they are made of silicone. The material itself doesn’t promote the growth of bacteria, which further adds to the safety feature of the pacifier.

Buy This From Amazon

Ensure that you choose the right size for your baby as per the directions and the age of the baby.

What Should You Consider Before Buying a Baby Pacifier?

Like any other product, options are limitless also in case of baby products. So, it is not easy to go through them all and choose the best one. Here are some of the essential things to keep in mind when choosing a pacifier for your baby –

Age – When it comes to choosing a pacifier for a baby, the age range is the first thing to consider. Are you thinking of using a pacifier from the beginning, and you are pregnant? Pick a pacifier that has been approved for newborns. If you want to pacify an older baby, buy one which is right for a specific age, such as three months to 6 months. There are also pacifiers for toddlers.

Pacifier nipples – It is another crucial thing to keep in mind. You should also consider them as well. There are two different types of pacifier nipples. You can go with a natural nipple or orthodontic one.

This orthodontic nipple is the one designed to protect the oral development of your baby. The natural nipple is usually more acceptable for babies. They are generally one-piece pacifiers. They are easier to clean and can last longer.

Price – Pacifiers also vary in cost. If you go with a costly pacifier and it suits your baby, there is no better investment than this. It is because you may not want to replace it time and time again. Consider your budget when it comes to replacing the pacifier.

Other features – Finally, you may also want to consider extras, which are essential. Some of the best examples are pacifier clips or puller to hold on the pacifier. Some pacifiers even come with cases and the ones which double as sterilization boxes.

Pacifier Do’s and Don’ts For Parents

Wait until the baby turns 3 to 4 weeks old – If you are breastfeeding your baby, it is suggested to wait for at least 3 to 4 weeks after birth, and your breastfeeding is well established.

Don’t use pacifier every now and then – Even a rocking session or change of position can calm a baby. Offer a pacifier only between or after feeding.

Choose dishwasher safe, one-piece silicone – Pacifiers which are made of two pieces are not safe if they break. You should also keep a few similar backups once you pick the best pacifier.

Let your baby settle down – If your baby doesn’t like the pacifier, you shouldn’t force it. If it falls off her mouth when sleeping, don’t pop it in again.

Sterilize – Before offering a pacifier to your baby, clean it thoroughly. Until she turns six months old, and her immune system improves, ensure you boil the pacifiers, or put them through the dishwasher. Once she turns six months old, wash the pacifiers with soapy water.

Don’t put anything sweet on the pacifier.

Keep the pacifier safe – Replace the pacifier and use the right size for the age of your baby. Look for signs of deterioration or lose parts. Be careful with pacifier clips. Never attach a pacifier to a strap or string long enough as it can get caught around the neck of your baby.

How To Care & Clean Baby Pacifiers

It is essential to take care of your baby pacifiers as they are prone to bacteria that are not visible to the human eye. Below are the steps that you need to follow for taking care and cleaning your baby pacifiers so that your baby is safe from any bacteria attacking them.

Firstly, it is essential to clean your pacifier correctly before sterilizing them. This is the first step. For this, you have to use hot water and soap. You can use a clean sink or a bowl to fill the boiling water. Then start cleaning the pacifier. Make sure you that you do not use the kitchen sponge as it has bacteria trapped in it. You can use a clean new one and keep it for future use whenever you wish to clean the pacifier.

Once the cleaning is done, just check the whole pacifier once again. You need to ensure that the pacifier is still useful for the baby and is cleaned well. When the pacifier life is done, it can form cracks or tears on the nipple part. This is not at all good for the baby.

When the baby starts sucking such a damaged pacifier, there is a chance that the torn part or some part of the pacifier can get stuck in the baby’s throat, which is dangerous. Also, check for the nipple being sticky even after cleaning it thoroughly. If it is sticky, that means the material is no longer suitable for the baby to suck. You need to throw these pacifiers out and buy new ones.

For sterilizing the baby pacifiers, you can use different methods. You can use boiling water, electric sterilizer, microwave sterilizer, or a dishwasher for sterilizing. For the boiling water method, you need to first heat some water to a full boil. Then, place the pacifier in the boiling water. You need to keep boiling it for 5 minutes. This is an effective method to kill the bacteria on the pacifier.

There are some electric sterilizers available in the market. Each has its own specifications, and you need to follow them thoroughly. These can be the ones that you bought for cleaning milk bottles. If your pacifier is microwave safe, you can put them in the microwave for some time based on the instructions given by the pacifier company.

Lastly, you can use the dishwasher to sterilize your pacifier. However, make sure that your pacifier is dishwasher safe. Also, you need to put your pacifier in the top rack rather than on the bottom.

  • One crucial step that you should not miss is that after sterilizing your pacifier, you need to dry it thoroughly. Some sterilizers have a unique feature for drying things. If you have that, you can use it. Else, air dry your pacifier and shake any excess water.
  • Once you clean the pacifiers, you might want to carry them out when your child needs one. Until their usage, you need to place them in safe zip-lock bags or a special compartment in your bag. This makes sure that the pacifier doesn’t come in contact with other items in the bag.


We have listed some of the safe, high-quality, and durable pacifiers for your baby, which are best for babies who are breastfeed. They help to soothe upset babies and avoid nipple confusion.

We hope some of our best picks and buying guide will help you choose one. These pacifiers will help your baby stay content when not feeding.